If you listen to
popular songs,
you might
conclude there’s
no day as
depressing as a
Monday. But a
new study shows
that lyricists
may have gotten
it all wrong and
that Wednesday
is really the
darkest day of
the week.
The study,
published in
Social
Psychiatry and
Psychiatric
Epidemiology,
found that
people are far
more likely to
kill themselves
in the middle of
the week than in
the beginning or
the end: almost
25 percent of
suicides occur
on Wednesdays as
compared to 14
percent on
Mondays or
Saturdays, the
two days tied
for
second-highest
suicide rates.
The study also
found if you
make it through
Wednesday, your
risk for suicide
plummets by more
than half the
following day;
Thursdays have
the lowest rate,
with only 11
percent of
suicides.
Research up
until now has
pointed a finger
at Mondays, said
the new report’s
lead author,
Augustine J.
Kposowa, a
professor of
sociology at the
University of
California,
Riverside.
"Everyone talks
about the Monday
blues," Kposowa
added. "But if
you look at more
recent data, it
looks like
things have
shifted and now
it’s the middle
of the week
that’s the
problem."
Story continues
below
?advertisement |
your ad here
More study is
needed to fully
understand the
findings, but
researchers
suspect that we
may be seeing a
positive impact
of technology on
suicide and
depression. With
the advent of
e-mail, Internet
discussion
groups and text
messaging,
people can now
stay in touch
with the outside
world even if
they are holed
up by themselves
at home the
entire weekend.
As for the spike
in suicides in
the middle of
the week,
Kposowa
suggested that
the increase may
indicate job
stress. "People
may be fed up
and stressed by
their jobs by
the middle of
the week," he
said. "By
Wednesday, the
traffic has
gotten to be too
much, their
co-workers are
getting on their
nerves and they
can’t figure out
how they’re
going to make it
to the end of
the week."
Why Wednesdays?
Kposowa and his
co-author
examined data on
deaths in people
over the age of
18 for five
years — 2000
through 2004 —
from all 50
states. On
average, the
researchers
found that there
were about
30,000 suicides
per year in this
group. The
researchers
detected another
interesting
change in the
suicide data.
Contrary to
earlier studies
that showed an
increased rate
of suicides in
winter and
spring, the new
data showed
almost no
seasonal effect
on suicide
rates. Slightly
more occurred in
the summer — 26
percent — while
the fewest
occurred in the
winter, at 23.8
percent.
Kposowa again
looks to the
nation’s higher
connectedness —
through the
Internet and
cell phones — to
explain the lack
of a seasonal
effect. Winter
just doesn’t
isolate people
as much as it
used to, he
said.
Suicide rates
by day of the
week
Day Suicide rate
(percent)
Sunday 11.8
Monday 14.3
Tuesday 12.7
Wednesday 24.6
Thursday 11.1
Friday 11.2
Saturday 14.4
Source:
"Association of
temporal factors
and suicides in
the United
States,
2000-2004" by
Augstine J.
Kposowa and
Stephanie
D'Auria • Print
this
The new study is
"intriguing and
provocative,"
said Dr. Alan
Manevitz, a
psychiatrist at
NewYork-Presbyterian
Hospital/Weill
Cornell Medical
Center. "It goes
against a lot of
what we take as
lore. We think
about the
classic problems
people have on
Sunday nights
thinking about
going back to
school or work,
and the winter
blues,
especially in
people with
Seasonal
Affective
Disorder."
The strength of
the new study is
that it looked
at the entire
country over
five years, said
Alexandre Y.
Dombrovski, a
research
assistant
professor in the
department of
psychiatry at
the University
of Pittsburgh
Medical Center.
But Dombrovski
cautioned
against reading
too much into
the Wednesday
effect. "While
it’s tempting to
conclude that
people choose
Wednesday
because it’s the
most stressful
day, you have to
remember that
many suicides
are premeditated
and they don’t
necessarily
occur as a
result of the
events on the
day the suicide
occurred," he
said.
Still, it is
possible that a
particularly
stressful day
can push someone
into
implementing
previously
devised plans,
Dombrovski
allowed.
Intervention
works
One important
message people
should take from
this study is
that there is no
day or season
when someone can
be considered to
be safe from
suicide,
Manevitz said.
Warning signs of
suicide
— Sudden changes
in personality
such as
irritability,
anxiety, anger,
apathy or
sadness
— Loss of
interest in
activities such
as sex or
socializing with
friends
— Loss of
enthusiasm for
hobbies and
other passions
— Changes in
sleep patterns
or eating habits
— Less attention
to personal
appearance
— Feelings of
guilt and shame
— Feelings of
worthlessness
and hopelessness
— Feelings of
anger and of
being trapped
— Preoccupation
with death and
dying; talking
about wanting to
die
— Increase in
risk taking and
reckless
behavior
— Isolation and
no sense of
purpose or
belonging
Note: A suicidal
person needs to
see a doctor or
mental health
professional or
to go to an
emergency room.
Source: Dr. Alan
Manevitz, a
psychiatrist at
NewYork-Presbyterian
Hospital/Weill
Cornell Medical
Center
"If someone you
know is showing
warning signs,
don’t take for
granted that
it’s not
something to
worry about
because of the
day of the week
or the season of
the year," he
cautioned.
"Friends and
family need to
take suicidal
ideation
seriously at all
times."
Any time someone
sounds
preoccupied with
death or seems
particularly
depressed about
their lives, you
need to follow
up, even if you
think they’re
just focusing on
small things,
Manevitz said.
"You should
never be afraid
to ask questions
like, ‘Are you
feeling so badly
that you’re
thinking about
suicide?’"
Evidence shows
that
intervention by
friends and
family members
works when it
comes to suicide
prevention,
Manevitz said.
"If you’re
worried about
suicide, don’t
leave the person
alone," he said.
"Don’t let him
isolate
himself."
Linda Carroll is
a health and
science writer
living in New
Jersey. Her work
has appeared in
The New York
Times, Newsday,
Health magazine
and SmartMoney.
© 2009 msnbc.com.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/31780455/ns/health-mental_health/